Welcome to Bailey Avenue Pizza
At Bailey Avenue Pizza, our story is intertwined with the heart of Buffalo, NY, where we serve up authentic Buffalo-style pizza. Founded with a passion for quality and tradition, we pride ourselves on delivering large, generously topped slices that embody the rich flavors of our community. Our pizza features thick, chewy dough, abundant mozzarella, and a sweet yet savory sauce, all harmoniously balanced with perfectly cupped pepperoni. Locals rave about our wings and appetizers, making us a go-to spot for satisfying meals. At Bailey Avenue Pizza, each visit is not just a meal; it’s a celebration of Buffalo’s vibrant culinary spirit.
-
2916 Bailey Ave, Buffalo, NY 14215 Hotline: (716) 837-4444
Welcome to Bailey Avenue Pizza, the go-to destination for pizza enthusiasts in Buffalo, New York. Nestled at 2916 Bailey Ave, this charming pizzeria works its magic not just on the palette, but also through its warm and inviting atmosphere. Whether you’re a local resident or just passing through, Bailey Avenue Pizza promises a dining experience that celebrates the classic Buffalo-style pizza.
This cozy establishment is particularly renowned for its hearty, generous slices that will leave your cravings satisfied. With a range of offerings, Bailey Avenue Pizza has something for everyone. From their quintessential cheese and pepperoni pizza to the interestingly topped options like cheese with beef pepperoni, each bite is an ode to quality ingredients and traditional preparation methods. You can enjoy a large cheese pizza for just $30, and the half pizzas, perfect for an individual or a light snack, start at $17.
But it's not just the pizza that's turning heads. The appetizers deserve a spotlight too! Indulge in their apple pie logs with caramel dip ($7.50) or the crispy jalapeño poppers ($6.00) for a delightful start to your meal. Don’t overlook the smoked gouda mac and cheese bites, which have even garnered rave reviews for their melt-in-your-mouth texture.
- Customer Favorites:
- Alisha C. noted, “Bailey Pizza is a perfect choice when you need an extra-large, hot, and cheesy slice on the go!”
- Ruth S. praised the “consistently fresh and abundant toppings,” calling the sauce “exceptional.”
- Clark S. described his experience as ideal for anyone craving “good, filling Buffalo-style pizza.”
As you step inside, you'll feel a sense of community; the staff are attentive, ensuring your experience is seamless from order to pick-up. The atmosphere may be simple, but it’s reflective of the true spirit of Buffalo dining—down-to-earth and genuine.
In addition, Bailey Avenue Pizza prides itself on their deals. Whether you are looking to feed a crowd or just yourself, try their everyday specials like 1/2 Pizza - Cheese with 10 Wings for $30, making it a bustling option for gatherings with friends and family.
In conclusion, if you're searching for a slice that embodies the essence of Buffalo, look no further than Bailey Avenue Pizza. With their dedication to quality ingredients, hearty portions, and consistent service, each visit is a reminder of why pizza is a beloved staple in our food culture. Next time you're in the area, swing by or give them a call at (716) 837-4444. You won’t be disappointed!
Bailey Pizza when you need an extra large hot and cheesy slice on the go. I've never had an issue with my slice being too small here. They've been pretty consistent from the start and always a go to for a "hot n ready" pizza slice that's bigger than your head lol
The toppings on this pizza are consistently fresh and abundant. The sauce is exceptional. It is one of my preferred pizza establishments in Buffalo, New York.
It doesn't get any better ! I always order large pizza with cheese pepperoni and mushrooms! Awesome! Thank you Bailey Avenue Pizza!
This pizza is the best thing that I ever had the wings are AMAZING LOVE the French fries great customer service and great pizza and a subs
Reputation may be a little concerning...lol...but overall the pizza is delicious and a nice size for the price of the slices
*Website: https://www.baileyavenuepizza.com/ Taking a cue from SexySlices, and since I live relatively close by, I decided to try out Bailey Avenue Pizza for dinner on a beautiful Saturday evening. All-in-all, they serve up a phenomenal Buffalo-style pizza! Around 5pm on a Saturday, I called and placed my pick-up order. The gentleman on the phone took my order and ran through it with me to ensure he had everything down. He came across fine, not overly friendly but definitely not standoff-ish or awkward. I was told it'd be ready in 30-40 minutes. I arrived around 35 minutes later and parked on the street next to their shop. I'll admit, the neighborhood comes across as being a bit rough, but I suppose that adds to the charm of the pizzeria itself. As soon as you walk in, it gives off Bocce Club on Bailey Ave. (Amherst) vibes, but smaller. The gentleman asked me for my name and brought my pizza out, double-checked it to ensure it was made correctly, then cashed me out - a five minute experience, not bad at all. The gentleman behind the counter was friendly and easy-going, so that was nice. So for dinner, I ordered a Half (9", eight slice) cheese and pepperoni pizza with bacon, sweet (red this time!) peppers, and onions, or as I refer to it as "The Clark Classic". This pizza is a textbook example of a Buffalo-style pizza! The mozzarella cheese on top as laid on thick and was creamy with a little hint of salt. Their red sauce was sweet-style, but not overly sweet, at least I didn't think so. In my opinion, it was the ideal balance between sweet and savory and paired amazingly well with the mozzarella cheese. The pepperoni was nicely cupped and charred on the edges and there were plenty of sweet red peppers and onions sliced on top. The sweet red pepper was a nice change-up from the regular green bell pepper. The bacon they used was excellent - Big, hearty, crispy pieces, definitely not finely diced or store-bought bacon bits. The dough and crust were totally Buffalo-style as the dough was fluffy and had great flavor and chew and the crust had a satisfying crunch to it without being charred beyond recognition. The size of this pizza is comparable to Bocce Club's or Imperial's "Half" size pizzas, so I definitely didn't walk away hungry. As for the price of this pizza, it was on the pricey side, so definitely not a pizza I'd be getting every weekend. Overall, Bailey Avenue Pizza serves up a fantastic traditional, Buffalo-style pizza, one that is quite literally textbook in look, quality, and taste! Their pizza menu is pretty limited, I noticed only two specialty pizzas, none being a chicken finger pizza, but that's alright. When I need just a good, filling Buffalo-style pizza, I'd definitely consider Bailey Avenue Pizza!
THIS is GREAT Buffalo style pizza! I am so glad I finally got to try this! Really easy ordering online and ready ASAP Rocky! We ordered a half cheese and Pepp well done (~$17ish) and wow yeah I bodied my respective slices with as much passion as I could muster. The half has about 8 very LARGE and dense slices. And the cup and char Pepp is done perfectly in good ol buffalo fashion. Dough is thick with good chew and flavour, light on the sauce (how I like it, in contrast to a more saucy buff style like imperial). Heavy on the cheese... the calcium gains we all need and great seasoning. I enjoyed every last finger licking moment here and will certainly be ordering again!! Thank you Bailey Ave pizza Crew!