Bailey Avenue Pizza Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Bailey Avenue Pizza, a gem nestled in Buffalo, NY. Famous for its authentic Buffalo-style pizza, this eatery serves a menu that’s simple yet satisfying. At the heart of the offering are their generously sized pizzas, from classic Cheese to the popular Cheese & Pepperoni, all boasting hearty toppings and exquisite flavors.
- Signature Pizzas: Enjoy options like the Cheese & Beef Pepperoni for a meat lover's paradise.
- Appetizers: Delight in crispy Jalapeño Poppers or cheesy Twisted Pretzels.
- Everyday Specials: Great deals on large pizza and wings combos ensure value with every bite.
With toppings described as fresh and abundant, and a perfect balance of sweet and savory sauce, Bailey Avenue Pizza invites you to indulge in a slice from their remarkable menu. Customers appreciate the consistent quality, generous portions, and friendly service, making this pizzeria a must-visit for pizza lovers.
Appetizers Everyday Specials Pizza Party Pizza Bailey Pizzeria Special Everything Pizza Special Pizza by the Slice Submarines 8" Submarines 12" CHICKEN WING Boneless Wings Chicken Fingers Soft Drinks Side of Sauce Dessert Tacos Loaded fries Salad Char pit Family Calzone STEAK PIZZA Monday Special Tuesday Special 10 Boneless Wings / fries half cold sub / fries 2 Tacos lunch special calzones
Appetizers
Mozzarella Stix
6 Pieces
$6.00
Pizza Logs
5 Pieces
$7.00
Fries
$5.00
Buffalo chicken logs
$7.50
Apple pie logs with Carmel dip
$7.50
Smoked Gouda Mac and cheese bites (10 pieces)
$6.00
Twisted pretzels with cheese dip ( 4 pieces )
$6.00
Onion rings
$5.00
Jalapeo poppers cheddar (5 piece)
$6.00
Jalapeo poppers sour cream (5 piece)
$6.00
Bread sticks (4)
$5.00
1/2 Pizza - Cheese 1 Ingredient & 10 Wings
$30.00
1/2 Pizza - Cheese 1 Ingredient & 20 Wings
$39.50
Large Cheese Pizza 1 Ingredient & 20 Wings
$53.50
Large Cheese Pizza 1 Ingredient & 30 Wings
$62.00
Large Cheese Pizza 1 Ingredient & 50 Wings
$77.50
Party Pizza 1 Ingredient & 50 Wings
$83.50
Everyday Specials
Pizza
Cheese (1/2)
$17.00
Cheese (Whole)
$30.00
Cheese & Pepperoni (1/2)
$19.00
Cheese & Pepperoni (Whole)
$33.00
Cheese & Beef Pepperoni (1/2)
$19.00
Cheese & Beef Pepperoni (Whole)
$33.00
Cheese (Party)
$38.00
Cheese & Pepperoni (Party)
$44.00
Party Pizza
Bailey Pizzeria Special
Bailey Pizzeria Special (Half)
Cheese, pepperoni, mushroom, sweet peppers, onions, green olives
$27.00
Bailey Pizzeria Special (Whole)
Cheese, pepperoni, mushroom, sweet peppers, onions, green olives
$42.00
Everything (Half)
Ground beef & meat balls available as pizza toppings
$28.00
Everything (Whole)
Ground beef & meat balls available as pizza toppings
$52.00
Chicken finger parm half
$27.00
Chicken finger park whole
$42.00
Chicken finger party
$69.00
Everything Pizza Special
Pizza by the Slice
Cheese & Pepperoni (Slice)
$5.00
Assorted 8"
$10.59
Bailey Pizzeria "Royal" 8"
Fried Italian sausage & capicola
$12.50
Baked Beef 8"
$12.50
Capicola 8"
$10.59
Cheese 8"
$7.50
Cheeseburger 8"
$11.00
Chicken - N- Cheese Parmesan 8"
$12.00
Chicken Finger 8"
$12.00
Fried Italian Sausage 8"
$11.50
Ham 8"
$8.50
Hamburger 8"
$9.50
Hard Salami 8"
$9.50
Hitman's Delight 8"
Fried Italian sausage, hard salami, capicola, peppers & onions
$12.50
Meat Ball 8"
$11.00
Meat Ball Parmesan 8"
$11.00
Stinger 8"
$14.00
Pizza Sub 8"
$10.50
Regular Steak Hoagie 8"
Fried onions & melted cheese
$12.50
Roast Beef 8"
$12.50
Sausage Hoagie 8"
$12.00
Sausage Parmesan 8"
$12.50
Steak & Cheese 8"
Lettuce & tomato
$12.00
Steak & Sausage Hoagie 8"
$14.00
Super Steak Hoagie 8"
Fried onions, mushrooms, hot & sweet peppers plus melted cheese
$13.00
Top of the Bailey Pizzeria Double Decker 8"
With ham, hard salami & capicola
$14.00
Tuna 8"
$10.00
BLT 8"
$11.00
Turkey & Bacon 8"
$12.00
Turkey Breast 8"
$10.00
Submarines 8"
Submarines 12"
Assorted 12"
$13.00
Bailey Pizzeria "Royal" 12"
Fried Italian sausage & capicola
$15.00
Baked Beef 12"
$15.00
Capicola 12"
$11.50
Cheeseburger 12"
$14.00
Chicken Parmesan 12"
$15.00
Chicken Finger 12"
$15.00
Fried Italian Sausage 12"
$14.00
Ham 12"
$11.00
Hamburger 12"
$12.00
Hard Salami 12"
$12.00
Hitman's Delight 12"
Fried Italian sausage, hard salami, capicola, peppers & onions
$15.00
Meat Ball 12"
$13.00
Meat Ball Parmesan 12"
$15.00
Stinger 12"
$15.50
Pizza Sub 12"
$12.50
Regular Steak Hoagie 12"
Fried onions & melted cheese
$15.00
Roast Beef 12"
$14.00
Sausage Hoagie 12"
$14.00
Sausage Parmesan 12"
$14.50
Steak & Cheese 12"
Lettuce & tomato
$15.00
Steak & Sausage Hoagie 12"
$16.00
Super Steak Hoagie 12"
Fried onions, mushrooms, hot & sweet peppers plus melted cheese
$16.00
Top of the Bailey Pizzeria Double Decker 12"
With ham, hard salami & capicola
$16.00
Tuna 12"
$12.00
BLT 12"
$14.00
Turkey & Bacon 12"
$15.00
Turkey Breast 12"
$13.00
Chicken hoagie
$15.00
Chicken hoagie super
$16.00
CHICKEN WING (10) NO ALL FLAT
$18.00
CHICKEN WING (20) NO ALL FLAT
$27.50
CHICKEN WING (30) NO ALL FLAT
$39.00
CHICKEN WING (50) NO ALL FLAT
$59.00
CHICKEN WING
Boneless Wings
Boneless Wings (10)
Wings and boneless wings can be split in half only HONEY MUSTARD IS OUT OF STOCK
$11.00
Boneless Wings (20)
Wings and boneless wings can be split in half only
$21.00
Boneless Wings (30)
Wings and boneless wings can be split in half only
$31.00
Boneless Wings (50)
Wings and boneless wings can be split in half only
$51.00
Chicken Finger (5)
$16.00
Chicken Finger (10)
$25.00
Chicken Finger (15)
$34.00
Chicken Fingers
Soft Drinks
Water Bottle
$1.00
1 Liter Bottle
$2.50
2 Liter Bottle
$3.50
gold peak
$2.00
Cans
$1.50
vitamin water
$1.75
minute maid fresca
$2.25
power ade
$2.00
20 oz
$2.00
Apple juice or orange juice
$2.25
Body armour
$2.25
MONSTER
ENERGY DRINK
$2.75
1.25 Ltd cherry coke
$2.75
Side of Blue Cheese
$1.00
Side of ranch
$1.00
Side of Steak Sauce
$1.00
Side of Marinara
$1.00
Side of Hot Buffalo
$1.00
Side of Medium Buffalo
$1.00
Side of Mild Buffalo
$1.00
Side of BBQ
$1.00
Side of Honey BBQ
$1.00
Side of Garlic Parm
$1.00
Side of Lemon Pepper
$1.00
Side of Kicken Burbon
$1.00
Side of Sweet Chili
$1.00
Side cellery
$1.00
side of honey mustard
$1.00
merinara
$1.00
side blk olive
$1.00
side green olives
$1.00
side banana peppers
$1.00
side anchovies
$2.00
side mushrooms
$1.00
side carrots
$1.00
French
$1.00
Thousand Island
$1.00
Golden Italian
$1.00
Nacho cheese
$1.00
Side of Sauce
Dessert
Triple chocolate cake slice
$4.00
Cinnamon coffee cake
$3.50
Raspberry drizzle cheese cake
$4.00
NY style strawberry drizzle cheese cake
$4.00
Red velvet cake
$4.00
strawberry cheesecake logs
$7.00
Carmel drizzle cheescake
$3.50
Carrot cake
$4.00
Plain cheesecake
$4.00
Chocolate drizzle cheese cake
$4.00
raspberry cheesecake logs
$7.00
Cream brul donut
$2.50
Blank
$0.00
Beef Tacos
$7.00
STEAK TACO
$9.00
CHICKEN FINGER TACO
$9.00
Tacos
Loaded fries
Loaded fries
$7.50
Steak extra charge
$2.00
Taco meat extra charge
$2.00
Sour cream
$1.00
chef salad
$8.00
julianne salad
$11.00
anti-pasta salad
$14.50
Salad
Char pit
10 char pit
$1.00
20 char pit
$2.00
30 char pit
$3.00
50 char pit
$5.00
family calzone
$24.00
mozzarella
$0.00
peppers hot
$1.00
sweet peppers
$1.00
onions
$1.00
mushrooms
$1.00
black olives
$1.00
green olives
$1.00
steak 5pieces
$5.00
chicken fingers 5 pieces
$5.00
anchovies
$8.00
pepperoni
$5.00
sausage
$5.00
beef pepperoni
$5.00
Family Calzone
STEAK PIZZA
STEAK PIZZA
$27.00
Monday Large Pizza
18" . Cheese + one item
$33.35
Monday Special
Tuesday Special
Tuesday Wings (10 Wings)
$17.83
Tuesday Wings (20 Wings)
$28.75
Tuesday Wings (30 Wings)
$39.10
Tuesday Wings (50 Wings)
$64.40
Plain boneless & fries
$10.00
Hot boneless & fries
$10.00
Medium boneless & fries
$10.00
Mild boneless & fries
$10.00
BBQ boneless & fries
$10.00
Honey BBQ boneless & fries
$10.00
Honey Mustard boneless & fries
$10.00
Garlic Parm boneless & fries
$10.00
Lemon Pepper boneless & fries
$10.00
Cajun boneless & fries
$10.00
Kicken Burbon boneless & fries
$10.00
Sweet Chilli boneless & fries
$10.00
T
$10.00
10 Boneless Wings / fries
half cold sub / fries
Assorted 8" & fries
$10.00
Capicola 8" & fries
$10.00
Cheese 8" & fries
$10.00
Ham 8" & fries
$10.00
Hard Salami 8" & fries
$10.00
Roast Beef 8" & fries
$10.00
Tuna 8" & fries
$10.00
BLT 8" & fries
$10.00
Turkey Breast 8" & fries
$10.00
2 Beef Tacos lunch special
$10.00
2 Tacos lunch special
calzones
Mini calzone
$10.00